Skip to main content

Table 1 Inclusion criteria

From: BreathCarer: Informal carers of patients with chronic breathlessness: a mixed-methods systematic review of burden, needs, coping, and support interventions

Review questions

Effectiveness and effect of interventions

Description of burden, needs, coping and healthcare/social service use of informal carers

Perception and experience of informal carers

Inclusion criteria

 Study design:

Quantitative studies

Qualitative studies

Analytica

Descriptive

Experimental studiesa

Observational studiesa

Descriptive studiesb

(original research)

Qualitative studies

(original research)

PICOc / PICod:

 Population

Informal carers of adult patients with chronic breathlessness due to cancer, COPD, CHF, ILD/IPF, MNDe

We define an informal carer as a person of any age providing physical, emotional or practical care and support to a relative or a friend, outside of the context of his/her professional work

Studies with mixed populations (patients and carers) were included if specific results for carers could be extracted

 Intervention/ Topic of Interest

Any intervention aiming to support, inform or train carers

Any quantitative description of burden, needs and coping of carers

Perception and experience of carers in caring or supporting patients

 Comparator

In studies with control group: standard care or any other intervention

(not applicable)

(not applicable)

 Outcome

Any outcome for carers specifically related to breathlessness, such as well-being, coping/mastery, knowledge, skills and health care/social service use

Any quantitative descriptive parameter on carers specifically related to breathlessness: prevalence, incidence, experience, etc

(not applicable)

 Context

Any setting in any country

  1. a In our understanding, analytical studies are studies attempting to quantify the relationship between the effect of an intervention and an outcome. If the researcher actively imposes an intervention, this is an experimental study. If he/she simply observes the effect of the exposure, this is an observational study, e.g., a cohort or a case–control study (based on CEBM, The Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, University of Oxford, https://www.cebm.net/2014/04/study-designs/)
  2. b E.g., surveys, case series or case reports
  3. c PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparator, Outcome) refers to four categories of inclusion criteria for quantitative (analytical) studies
  4. d PICo (Population, topic of Interest, Context) applies for qualitative studies
  5. e COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease), CHF (chronic heart failure), ILD (interstitial lung disease)/IPF (idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis), MND (motor neurone disease)