number | The title of the clinical guideline | Scope and purpose % | Stakeholder involvement % | Rigour of development % | Clarity of presentation % | Applicability % | Editorial independence % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | NICE (2015).[23] | 91/6 | 80/5 | 69/7 | 72/2 | 64/5 | 54/16 |
2 | NICE (2011) [31]. | 40/2 | 40/2 | 30/20 | 31/19 | 31/21 | 56/25 |
3 | NICE (2020) [21]. | 96/29 | 90/74 | 83/33 | 98/14 | 83/33 | 86/11 |
4 | Crawford, M et al. (2021) [22] | 88/88 | 81/94 | 85/41 | 90/27 | 66/66 | 68/75 |
5 | NICE. (2009) [36]. | 40/27 | 52/77 | 39/58 | 51/38 | 37/5 | 64/58 |
6 | NICE. (2015) [38]. | 94/44 | 86/11 | 80/20 | 65/27 | 57/29 | 83/33 |
7 | NICE. (2017) [39]. | 33/33 | 20/37 | 24/52 | 38/88 | 25 | 38/88 |
8 | Thornicroft, G et al. (2018) [32]. | 61/11 | 71/92 | 61/80 | 50 | 45/83 | 61/11 |
9 | MOH. (2014)[37] | 41/66 | 45/83 | 45/31 | 72/22 | 45/83 | 56/25 |
10 | Santa Mina, E et al. (2009) [20]. | 64/81 | 62/96 | 70/83 | 79/62 | 63/88 | 61/11 |
11 | Couroupis, A et al. [24] | 76/38 | 72/22 | 63/54 | 50 | 44/79 | 54/16 |
12 | NICE. (2016) [25]. | 91/66 | 81/94 | 64/06 | 75 | 46/87 | 66/66 |
13 | de la Cámara Izquierdo, C et al. (2009).[33] | 50 | 48/61 | 57/29 | 65/27 | 68/75 | 68/75 |
14 | Addington, Donald et al. (2017) [34]. | 41/42 | 33/33 | 39/06 | 48/61 | 32/29 | 64/58 |
15 | A. Keepers, G et al. [35] | 70/37 | 61/11 | 76/38 | 79/62 | 68/05 | 72/22 |
Mean scores | 65/49 | 62/03 | 59/41 | 64/51 | 52/11 | 63/79 |